El-Erian, Krugman, and various economists hold divergent views regarding the challenges faced by China’s economy.

China’s economic troubles are evident as its property market crumbles, deflationary pressures spread, and the stock market experiences significant volatility. The CSI 300 index has lost around 40% of its value from the 2021 peaks. January PMI numbers revealed the fourth consecutive month of contraction in manufacturing activity due to declining demand.

This pessimistic data has fueled skepticism about the second-largest global economy. Allianz has revised its optimistic view, forecasting a lowered average growth rate of 3.9% for Beijing’s economy between 2025 and 2029. Eswar Prasad, a former IMF official, suggests a diminishing likelihood of China surpassing the U.S. in GDP.

Despite these challenges, Chinese leader Xi Jinping remains optimistic about the nation’s economic resilience. However, experts like Nobel laureate Paul Krugman foresee an era of stagnation, attributing China’s struggles to issues like poor leadership and high youth unemployment.

The property market crisis is a significant concern, with the IMF anticipating a 50% drop in housing demand over the next decade. Hedge fund manager Kyle Bass compares China’s property market issues to the U.S. financial crisis on steroids, stating that the basic architecture of the Chinese economy is broken.

While some, like the Institute of International Finance, believe that China has the policy capacity to drive economic growth, others emphasize the need for structural reforms and demand-side stimulus. Clocktower Group’s Marko Papic offers a short-term optimistic view, predicting a 10% to 15% rally in Chinese equities. JPMorgan Private Bank also outlines bullish scenarios, highlighting China’s resilient role as a global manufacturer, despite challenges in the stock and property markets.

Looking ahead, China faces hurdles, and its ability to overcome them remains uncertain.